1856 – 1858 D. L. Winslow
1858 – 1859 Henry Minard
1859 – 1860 J. B. Rockwell
1860 – 1861 J. H. Grant
1861 – 1862 S. P. Lott
1862 – 1864 J. B. Rockwel
1864 – 1866 W. H. Fisher
1866 – 1869 J. F. Hanna
1869 – 1872 Sanford Washburn
1872 – 1873 F. Curtis
1873 – 1877 J. B. McGuffin
1877 – 1878 W. H. Tibbles
1878 – 1881 Jacob H. Hartman
1881 – 1882 J. R. Burns
1882 – 1883 Robert Proctor
1883 – 1886 C. C. Lovejoy
1886 – 1891 J. W. Richards
1891 – 1894 Henry Lea
1894 – 1898 William H. Pierce
1898 – 1901 E. J. Rose
1901 – 1904 F. R. McNamera
1904 – 1906 J. P. Davies
1906 – 1909 H. E. Sweitzer
1909 – 1910 F. J. Milnes
1910 – 1912 E. L. Meservey
1912 – 1913 C. Lemont Hay
1913 – 1915 A. L. Fisher
1915 – 1919 N. R. Hinds
1919 – 1920 M. J. Fields
1920 – 1921 Reuben M. Furnish
1921 – 1925 James A. Wilson
1925 – 1927 H. L. Eagle
1927 – 1929 I. A. Woodrow
1929 – 1933 O. L. Jones
1933 – 1935 E. Lester Stanton
1935 – 1939 J. H. Hagerty
1939 – 1942 Elias W. Ward
1942 – 1947 L. Harold George
1947 – 1954 W. J. Hopkins
1954 – 1958 Virgil A. Chilcote
1958 – 1959 Harold Stevens
1959 – 1963 Palmer E. Matthews
1963 – 1971 Henry J. Holverson
1971 – 1980 Wayne R. Wachholz
1980 – 1984 Kathleen J. Hendricks
1984 – 1988 Robert King
1988 – 1995 Tom Kingery
1995 – 2001 Judy Giese
2001 – 2004 Richard Shelton
2004 – 2011 Christina Vosteen

2011 – 2016 Kent Svendsen

2016 – 2023 Stevan Saunders (Last United Methodist Church of Plano pastor) 

2023-Current Stevan Saunders (First Plano Methodist Church pastor)